The Next
Generation Internet: Unsafe at any speed?
Kenneth P. Birman, Cornell
University
There is a debate concerning the future directions that the
Internet should take. Support has been building for the Next
Generation Internet (NGI) Initiative, which would greatly enhance
the performance and scalability of the current Internet, while also
providing improved Internet access for K-12 schools and investing in
new kinds of Internet uses, such as for providing government
services over the network. These include safety, revenue and
life-critical systems which have traditionally been developed using
special-purpose computing technology. The NGI envisions a steady
transition of such systems onto a commercial off-the-shelf
technology base. There really isn't any alternative; only standard
technologies yield cost-effective systems. But this begs the
question: What needs to be done to transform the current Internet
into the NGI, if critical applications will run upon it? In
particular, if the current Internet is unsafe for such applications,
why should we expect the NGI to be more safe? The talk suggests that
as things stand, the NGI will not be safe for critical uses, but
also shows how a simple "virtual overlay network" capability could
be developed to plug the major deficiency.